Holy Hurt: Key Insights & Takeaways from Hillary L. McBride

For many believers, some of the deepest wounds they carry come not from the world but from the church. Hillary L. McBride's Holy Hurt offers compassionate guidance for those navigating the painful terrain of spiritual trauma—showing how the very wounds inflicted by religious experiences can become sacred pathways to genuine transformation and renewed faith.

This guide unpacks McBride's integrated approach to healing from religious harm. You'll discover why spiritual wounds affect body, mind, and soul simultaneously, how to rebuild a relationship with God after trauma, and why your deepest pain can become a source of wisdom and compassion for others walking similar paths.

Start practicing Holy Hurt ▸

How do religious experiences cause spiritual wounds?

Religious experiences can inflict deep psychological and spiritual wounds through shame-based theology, spiritual bypassing, and authoritarian power structures that deny human dignity and authentic questioning. When churches or religious leaders use faith as a weapon—teaching that doubt is sin, that bodies are shameful, or that submission to authority is the highest virtue—they create conditions for lasting harm.

McBride identifies specific categories of spiritual wounding that require recognition before healing can begin. Betrayal trauma occurs when trusted spiritual leaders abuse their position. Purity culture damage leaves lasting marks on how people relate to their bodies and sexuality. Theological abuse happens when distorted teachings about God create fear, shame, and self-hatred rather than the freedom Christ offers.

This matters because many who've experienced religious harm don't have language for what happened to them. They may feel that their pain isn't legitimate because it came from something that was supposed to be good. McBride validates these experiences while pointing toward hope—not by minimizing the harm, but by acknowledging it fully as the first step toward healing.

Why is acknowledging spiritual pain essential for healing?

Acknowledging spiritual pain is essential because denial and minimization keep wounds festering beneath the surface, while compassionate recognition creates space for authentic transformation. Many people who've been hurt by religion have been told—often by that same religious system—to suppress their questions, ignore their pain, and simply "have more faith."

McBride challenges this approach. Healing begins when we stop pretending we're fine and instead bring our wounds into the light. This isn't wallowing in victimhood; it's honest acknowledgment that something real happened and it caused real damage. Scripture itself models this through the Psalms of lament, where David and others bring their raw pain before God without pretense.

The body often knows what the mind has tried to forget. Spiritual trauma frequently manifests through physical symptoms like chronic tension, digestive issues, and panic responses because the body holds memories of religious harm that the conscious mind may have buried. Acknowledging pain means listening to these bodily signals as important messengers, not problems to be silenced. Loxie can help you internalize these insights about recognizing and honoring your own healing journey, so the wisdom becomes part of how you approach your story.

Practice these concepts in Loxie ▸

Why does religious trauma require an integrated healing approach?

Religious trauma requires an integrated healing approach combining theological reflection, psychological understanding, and somatic awareness because spiritual wounds affect our beliefs, emotions, and physical bodies simultaneously. A purely intellectual approach—simply learning better theology—won't reach the fear stored in your nervous system. But therapy alone may not address the theological distortions that shaped your understanding of God.

McBride weaves together multiple streams of healing. Theological reflection helps distinguish between harmful religious systems and authentic Christian faith—recognizing that the church that wounded you may have misrepresented the God who loves you. Psychological understanding provides frameworks for processing trauma, grief, and the complex emotions that accompany spiritual harm. Somatic awareness honors the body's role in holding and healing from trauma.

This integrated approach reflects a biblical anthropology that sees humans as unified beings—not souls trapped in bodies, but embodied souls. When Jesus healed people, he often addressed their whole person. McBride invites readers into a similarly holistic healing process that honors every dimension of who they are.

What is somatic awareness and why is it crucial for processing religious trauma?

Somatic awareness is the practice of befriending bodily sensations, using breathing practices, and engaging in gentle movement to restore safety and agency—and it's crucial for processing religious trauma because the body stores memories and responses that must be addressed for complete healing. You cannot simply think your way out of trauma; the body must be involved.

McBride explains that spiritual trauma often lodges in our physical being. A survivor of authoritarian religious leadership might feel their shoulders tense and chest tighten in any church setting, even a healthy one. Someone wounded by purity culture may experience shame as a visceral sensation of nausea or the urge to disappear. These responses aren't weakness or lack of faith—they're the body's protective mechanisms operating as designed.

Somatic practices for spiritual healing

Specific somatic practices support spiritual healing integration by helping release trauma stored in the body and creating embodied experiences of safety and divine connection. McBride recommends breathwork that activates the parasympathetic nervous system, signaling safety to a body on high alert. Body scanning practices help identify where tension, pain, or numbness reside. Movement meditation allows the body to express and release what words cannot capture.

These aren't new-age additions to Christian faith but recoveries of what embodied spirituality has always meant. The Incarnation—God taking on human flesh in Christ—dignifies our bodies as sites of sacred encounter. Practices that honor the body's wisdom align with a theology that sees physical existence as good, not as a prison from which souls must escape.

Healing insights need repetition to become embodied truth
Understanding somatic healing intellectually is different from having these practices become natural responses. Loxie uses spaced repetition to help these concepts move from your head to your habits—so when your body signals distress, you remember what McBride teaches.

Download Loxie for free ▸

How can you rebuild a relationship with the divine after spiritual trauma?

Rebuilding a relationship with the divine after trauma requires careful reimagining through distinguishing between harmful religious systems and authentic spirituality, allowing anger and grief toward God, and discovering new images of the sacred that feel safe and life-giving. This process cannot be rushed—it requires patience with yourself and often looks nothing like a linear progression.

McBride acknowledges what many trauma survivors feel but fear to say: it's okay to be angry at God. The Psalms model this raw honesty. "How long, O Lord? Will you forget me forever?" (Psalm 13:1). Suppressing this anger to appear spiritually mature only drives it underground where it festers. Expressing it honestly—even shouting it—can paradoxically open space for genuine encounter with God.

Part of this rebuilding involves distinguishing God from those who hurt you in God's name. The pastor who shamed you is not God. The theology that terrorized you may have been a distortion, not the truth. This distinction isn't about excusing harm but about refusing to let those who misrepresented God have the final word on who God actually is.

Discovering new images of the sacred

For many survivors, the images of God they inherited—stern judge, demanding father, harsh king—trigger trauma responses rather than drawing them into worship. McBride invites readers to explore other biblical images: God as mother hen gathering her chicks, as healer of the brokenhearted, as the one who binds up wounds. These aren't replacing Scripture but recovering dimensions of God's character that harmful theology may have suppressed.

This process of rebuilding isn't abandoning faith but deepening it. Many who walk this path emerge with a more robust, tested, and genuinely personal relationship with God than they had before their wounds. They know God not from hearsay but from having encountered divine presence in their darkest valleys.

Why are safe relationships essential for recovering from spiritual wounds?

Safe relationships characterized by non-judgmental presence, emotional attunement, and consistent reliability are essential for recovering from spiritual wounds because they provide the secure base needed to process trauma and rebuild trust. Spiritual trauma often happens in relationship—through leaders, communities, or families—so healing must also happen in relationship.

McBride emphasizes that we cannot heal in isolation. The wounds inflicted by community require the medicine of community—but this time, a different kind of community. Safe relationships are marked by people who can sit with pain without trying to fix it, who don't quote Bible verses at you when you need to be heard, and who earn trust through consistent, reliable presence over time.

This doesn't mean you need to find perfect people. Safe relationships are created by imperfect people who are committed to honesty, repair when they fail, and genuine care for your wellbeing over their own comfort. One safe relationship can be enough to begin. Loxie helps reinforce these insights about what safe relationships look like, so you can recognize and cultivate them in your own healing journey.

Start retaining what you learn ▸

What role do healing communities play in spiritual restoration?

Healing communities that practice radical acceptance, shared vulnerability, and collective witness provide the essential context for spiritual restoration by creating spaces where wounded faith can be safely explored and reconstructed. While individual safe relationships are crucial, there's something unique about finding a community that can hold your story.

McBride describes healing communities as places where you don't have to pretend, where doubt is welcomed as honest seeking rather than condemned as failure, and where people bear witness to each other's pain without trying to explain it away. These communities practice what theologians call "the ministry of presence"—simply being with someone in their suffering.

Not every church is a healing community. Some religious spaces, even well-intentioned ones, may trigger more harm than healing for trauma survivors. Discernment is required. McBride encourages readers to notice how their bodies respond in different community settings—this somatic feedback is valuable information about whether a space is safe for them.

What spiritual practices support healing from religious trauma?

Concrete spiritual practices like contemplative prayer, sacred reading with trauma-informed interpretation, and ritual creation integrate healing into daily life by providing regular touchpoints for processing pain and cultivating renewed faith. These practices look different than the religious activities that may have caused harm, honoring the need for new containers for spirituality.

Contemplative prayer differs from the performance-oriented prayer many experienced in harmful religious settings. It involves simply resting in God's presence without words, without demands, without the pressure to produce spiritual experiences. For trauma survivors, this can be profoundly healing—a way of encountering God that doesn't trigger associations with past harm.

Sacred reading with trauma-informed interpretation approaches Scripture differently than the weaponized Bible verses many survivors encountered. It reads with curiosity rather than fear, holds questions as valuable, and notices when passages trigger physical responses that need attention before intellectual engagement.

Creating new rituals

Ritual creation allows survivors to mark significant moments in their healing journey. McBride encourages creating personal or communal rituals that honor grief, celebrate milestones in healing, or provide tangible ways to let go of what no longer serves. These aren't arbitrary inventions but ways of making invisible spiritual realities tangible and embodied.

These practices form the architecture of sustainable spiritual health. They're not one-time interventions but ongoing rhythms that support continued growth and integration. Loxie can help you remember these practices and their purposes, transforming isolated insights into integrated daily habits.

How do you rewrite your spiritual narrative after religious trauma?

Rewriting spiritual narratives after religious trauma creates new meaning by actively reclaiming agency over your story, integrating painful experiences into a coherent whole, and authoring a faith narrative that honors both wounds and wisdom. This isn't about denying what happened but about refusing to let trauma have the final word on your identity.

McBride emphasizes that trauma survivors often feel their stories were taken from them—written by others, defined by harm, reduced to victimhood. Rewriting your narrative is an act of resistance and reclamation. You acknowledge what happened, grieve what was lost, and then actively choose what meaning these experiences will hold going forward.

This process involves seeing yourself as the protagonist of your own story rather than a passive victim of circumstances. It means recognizing the resilience you showed in surviving, the wisdom you gained through suffering, and the person you're becoming through healing. The wounds remain part of your story, but they don't define it.

How can brokenness become a site of sacred encounter?

Brokenness becomes a site of sacred encounter when we stop trying to fix ourselves and instead listen to what our wounds reveal about divine presence meeting us in vulnerability and pain. This is perhaps McBride's most profound insight: our wounds aren't obstacles to spirituality but potential doorways into deeper encounter with God.

The Christian faith centers on a wounded God. Christ bears scars even in his resurrected body. The cross reveals divine solidarity with human suffering, not divine distance from it. McBride invites readers to approach their wounds not as shameful failures but as places where they might be surprised to find God already present, already at work.

This doesn't mean spiritualizing suffering in ways that minimize it or suggest you needed trauma to grow. Rather, it recognizes that since the wounds exist, they can become sacred ground—places where you meet God in ways you never could have without walking through darkness. The wound itself becomes a window.

Try Loxie for free ▸

How do spiritual wounds become pathways to transformation?

Spiritual wounds become sacred pathways to transformation when we approach them with compassionate curiosity rather than shame, allowing pain to teach us about resilience and deepen our capacity for authentic connection. This isn't spiritual bypassing that skips over suffering but transformation that moves through it.

McBride describes how those who've been wounded and healed often possess capacities they couldn't have developed any other way. They understand suffering from the inside. They can sit with others in pain without rushing to fix it. They know the difference between cheap comfort and genuine presence. These are hard-won gifts born from hard places.

The transformation isn't instant or automatic. It requires the patient work of healing described throughout McBride's book—the integrated approach, the safe relationships, the somatic practices, the spiritual disciplines. But for those who walk this path, something genuinely new emerges from what was broken.

How do healed wounds become sources of wisdom and compassion?

Healed wounds become sources of wisdom and compassion by transforming our deepest pain into empathy for others' suffering and insights that can only come from having walked through darkness ourselves. Henri Nouwen called this the "wounded healer"—one whose own healing becomes a gift to others.

McBride shows how those who've done the hard work of healing from spiritual trauma often become uniquely equipped to accompany others on similar journeys. They've walked the path. They know its terrain. They can say with authenticity, "I know something of what you're experiencing, and there is hope."

This doesn't mean rushing to help others before you've tended to your own healing. Wounds that haven't healed can't offer healing to others—they just bleed on people. But wounds that have been brought to God, processed with care, and integrated into your story can become wells of living water for others thirsting for hope.

What creates sustainable spiritual health after religious trauma?

Integrated healing creates sustainable spiritual health by weaving together psychological insight, embodied practices, community support, and renewed faith into a holistic approach that honors both your wounds and your wholeness. This isn't a quick fix but a new way of living.

McBride's vision of sustainable spiritual health includes ongoing practices that maintain healing gains while continuing growth. It involves communities that support rather than harm. It requires a relationship with God that's honest enough to include lament, doubt, and anger alongside praise. And it embraces your body as a trusted ally rather than an enemy to be subdued.

Sustainable spiritual health also means accepting that healing isn't arriving at a final destination where wounds no longer matter. Instead, it's developing the capacity to hold your story with compassion, to notice when old patterns resurface, and to access the resources—internal, relational, and divine—that support ongoing wholeness.

The real challenge with Holy Hurt

Reading Holy Hurt may stir deep recognition and even hope. McBride's insights can illuminate your experience, validate your pain, and point toward genuine healing. But understanding these concepts intellectually is very different from having them shape how you actually navigate your healing journey day by day.

How many books about trauma and healing have you read that resonated deeply in the moment but whose wisdom you struggle to access when you're triggered, overwhelmed, or losing hope? The forgetting curve is especially cruel with material this important—insights you need most when you're struggling are often hardest to recall precisely because you're struggling.

Sustainable transformation requires more than a single reading. It requires the kind of repeated engagement that moves truth from your head into your habits, from concepts you know to capacities you embody.

How Loxie helps you actually remember what you learn

Loxie uses spaced repetition and active recall—the same techniques behind the most effective learning systems—to help you internalize McBride's insights so they're available when you need them most. Instead of reading once and hoping the wisdom sticks, you practice for about 2 minutes a day with questions that resurface key concepts right before you'd naturally forget them.

This isn't about memorizing facts. It's about internalizing truths so deeply that they shape how you respond to triggers, how you approach relationships, and how you relate to God. When your body signals distress, you want McBride's wisdom about somatic awareness to be readily accessible—not buried somewhere in a book you read months ago.

The free version of Loxie includes Holy Hurt in its topic library, so you can begin reinforcing these healing insights immediately. For those doing the sacred work of recovering from spiritual trauma, having these truths become second nature could make the difference between insights that inspire and wisdom that transforms.

Sign up free and start retaining ▸